July 4, 2024
Subscribe
The Real Crime Diary Blog Legal and Courtroom Are the new criminal laws better or worse? | India's Top Lawyers | Sibal, AM Singhvi, Mukul Rohatgi
Legal and Courtroom

Are the new criminal laws better or worse? | India's Top Lawyers | Sibal, AM Singhvi, Mukul Rohatgi

  • by
  • June 19, 2024
  • 39 Comments
  • 1 minute read
  • 10 Views
  • 2 weeks ago



India’s top lawyers and Senior Advocates of the Supreme Court of India – Kapil Sibal, Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Kapil Sibal discuss the new criminal laws introduced by the Narendra Modi government that are set to take effect from July 1. Are these laws a boon or a bane? Will they make the criminal jurisprudence faster or increase the burden on the existing system? Watch the discussion!

(This video is courtesy Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal’s YouTube channel ‘Dil Se With Kapil Sibal’)

Law Today brings you the latest breaking developments in the world of law and courts. Law Today keeps you up to date on all that is happening in Courts across the country along with analyzing legal issues that concern you. We bring you the top legal voices from India including judges, senior advocates, legal scholars and more. For ideas, suggestions and feedback, write to us at [email protected]

Subscribe to Law Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you’ll never miss a new video.

All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!

Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of legal news from India and around the world!

WEBSITE:
TWITTER:
FACEBOOK:
INSTAGRAM:

#NewCriminalLaws #KapilSibal #AMSinghvi #MukulRohatgi #LawToday #CriminalJurisprudence #IndianLaw #LegalDebate #NarendraModi #LawReform #SupremeCourt

source

Tags:

Share This Post:

39 Comments

  • Reply
    @arogyadassa1137 June 19, 2024

    What is there is enough

  • Reply
    @arogyadassa1137 June 19, 2024

    Is our government democratic or dictatorship, why allow such leaders to continue even though they have minority status and put them out

  • Reply
    @shreeshchandrapandey3033 June 19, 2024

    First thing is we must know how much time was taken by Macaulay commission to impose penal Code. if we break with the past we must consider the every change has to be weighed in golden scales for the reason human beings are habituated to past . Change could be worse remedy than the disease. If a person is imprisoned and ask him to prove prima facie that he may not be guilty laughable. Our Policemen seize the tools which may prove some light on probabable innocence. Broad question is : Is this not compulsion to give evidence against yourself against the guarantee under Article 20(2) of the constitution. It is known as testimonial compulsion in America.

  • Reply
    @VermaRajinder June 19, 2024

    Whatever Narendra Modi does is FuckAll —- All that matters is freedom to legislate till the Government is Dropped into Exhaustion. First you ensure delay thereafter you USE the same delay to say justice delayed is justice denied and therefore the Criminal HAS to be set free !!! Utimately what is Achieved – We have extremely Rich Defence Lawyers like these three and Absolutely NO CHANGE on Ground – Crime is becoming more Macabre and at the same time extremely Sophisticated in terms of Circumventing the Judicial Process !!! Who are responsible ??? These three triple test Practitioners !!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • Reply
    @rakeshchaudhary5190 June 19, 2024

    ALL THESE EXPERTS AND THE JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT
    CAN THEY ANSWER MY ONE QUESTION IS THAT WHY WE NEED A CONSTITUTION ? WHAT OS THE PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES OF THE C9NSTITUTION ? WELL LET ALL THE LEGAL LUMINARIES IN THE LEGAL FRATERNITY MIST ANSWER THIS QUESTION TO EXPAIN THIS ?

  • Reply
    @SeemaDevi-nd3vh June 19, 2024

    Good evening and Namaste Sir.Kapil Sibal sir.Mukul sir and Singhvi sir Namaste.

  • Reply
    @prasantamohanty3354 June 19, 2024

    Whatever you both lawers tells the public , all facts are justified and others who actually thinks or do something for national interest are wrong. The lawers are mostly liers and fabricators , accumulating money by their fake agenda and you are one of them , lier,.

  • Reply
    @BimalGhosh-nm6rf June 19, 2024

    Really enriched.

  • Reply
    @shajicherian8983 June 19, 2024

    Legends of Laws

  • Reply
    @sabya_m June 19, 2024

    Some panel.
    An for-ever-more, all-too,..awesome, "insightful",..discussion. Conversation.
    Respects. Regards.

  • Reply
    @rajindersinghsaroha1965 June 19, 2024

    Why Electoral Bond should be given to Political Parties. This has converted to Corruption system legally to influence the Political Parties in Power.

  • Reply
    @biswanathbhandari7028 June 19, 2024

    A piece of legislation can never be dissociated from its hidden agenda or motives. If means justify the ends then these highly debatable pieces of legislations lack larger democratic sanctity and moral validity. These draconian measures are bulldozed through without a proper scope for full flegded discussion and scrutiny in the parliament.In the hands of an authoritarian autocracy with its stated antagonism for individual rights and liberties these laws like all other identical versions are most likely to be used as tools of tyranny to torment more maliciously all the opposition stalwarts. Law can easily become an instrument of lawlessness when the mind presiding over it is highly malignant and potentially mischievous. These laws are not commensurate with the spirit and character of the constitutional democracy with its emphasis on personal space and freedom. Are we moving towards a police state?

  • Reply
    @harishdas5979 June 19, 2024

    Definitely the discussion was very interesting and Mr. Rastogi highlighted certain factual issues of the judiciary countering Mr. Singhvi's statements. There lies the truth 👍

  • Reply
    @p.balakrishnarow2962 June 19, 2024

    I feel that the erudite legal luminaries are thinking by standing in the shoes of advocates of both plaintiffs and defendants. Instead why police remad let the accused be given house arrest and available to police to interrogation from morning to evening allowing them house arrest during night.

  • Reply
    @SRB7805 June 19, 2024

    Its not difficult to understand what is to be done as by the SC. If it's not happening what can be done to bring change specifically in relation to the priority of cases? Is there a way out of the present situations where the process of the prosecution itself becomes the punishment! Unfortunately often times nothing gets proven after remaining in custody!

  • Reply
    @TheSwaraj June 19, 2024

    We know what Kapil Sibbal would like to say in the video. No need to see it.

  • Reply
    @baqirhemraj7639 June 19, 2024

    Freedom under the Indian Constitution is more important than draconian powers and criminalising acts for the benefit of PM Modi. PM Modi needs to go to school and learn rather than rely on his fake degrees. There is no evidence against the opposition who have been imprisoned without any charges and for those criminals who have joined the BJP, the law enforcers cannot find evidence despite clear evidence.

  • Reply
    @lakshmikantham2311 June 19, 2024

    Wonderful discussion. We ate aware of a few matters about jurisprudence and functioning of courts etc. The pity is that lakhs os cases are pending in the courts for decades together. Priority of the case or seniority of the case is to be judged and justified. No doubt there are flaws in the system which have to be set right for cherishing of the subjects. The lawyers are to be questioned in this context are they really fighing in the courts for justice and many clients have become paupers being unable to pat the highest fee and un wanted postponement of the cases for years together. No justice no happy in larger number of cases. My opinion is thay lawyers too look in to the cases whether there is justice in thse that comes to him and then fight in the court. Simply accepting the case and forward with the twisting techniques is not fair as many clients are suffering being got their finances are emptied and agony makes him either die or run away somewhere to hide his face. And so so sirs Thank you respected sirs.

  • Reply
    @Duleybhai June 19, 2024

    Nice discussion, thanks

  • Reply
    @abhishekdixit2912 June 19, 2024

    ☠️ मेरा कमेंट हटा दिया जायेगा ।
    आमतौर पर उग्रवादियों और ऎसे भृष्ट लोग, जो देश के लिए खतरा होते हैं, दूसरे देशों में उनको बचाने के लिए कोई वकील आगे नहीं आता । यह उनका अपने राष्ट्र के प्रति प्रेम व ठोस चरित्र है ।

    सिबल और सिंघवी वो वकील हैं, जिनकी दाल रोटी, राष्ट्र के द्रोहियों को बचाने में कमाये पैसों से चलती है ।
    इनको आम जनता समझती है और घटिया चरित्र के लोगों में इनकी गिनती करती है ।
    भगवान इनके साथ न्याय करे ।

  • Reply
    @abhishekdixit2912 June 19, 2024

    आमतौर पर उग्रवादियों और ऎसे भृष्ट लोग, जो देश के लिए खतरा होते हैं, दूसरे देशों में उनको बचाने के लिए कोई वकील आगे नहीं आता । यह उनका अपने राष्ट्र के प्रति प्रेम व ठोस चरित्र है ।

    सिबल और सिंघवी वो वकील हैं, जिनकी दाल रोटी, राष्ट्र के द्रोहियों को बचाने में कमाये पैसों से चलती है ।
    इनको आम जनता समझती है और घटिया चरित्र के लोगों में इनकी गिनती करती है ।
    भगवान इनके साथ न्याय करे ।

  • Reply
    @user-lo4oe6pj4e June 19, 2024

    Admire Mr Sibal sir for discussing the concerns of the public 👏 …thanks

  • Reply
    @Sudarshan-Advocate-Labrador June 19, 2024

    Strict laws more vulnerable to poor and middle class who cant able to pay fees to advocate

  • Reply
    @anoopzutshi7752 June 19, 2024

    Today we hv most corrupt police force and can't be trusted

  • Reply
    @subratade9620 June 19, 2024

    Positive type of decent discussion than media with self interested politicians.

  • Reply
    @shekhgulamjilani3738 June 19, 2024

    Please keep this sorts of intelligible discussion continue with such sort of intellectuals rationally sir

  • Reply
    @sureshhegde7316 June 19, 2024

    What about Politically or non politically motivated agitation turning in to rage to disturb public life.. Public wealth..

  • Reply
    @sureshhegde7316 June 19, 2024

    Sir With due respect.. Please put forward all needed criminal laws to be upgraded❤ With due respect to constitution

  • Reply
    @radhikatapaswi3164 June 19, 2024

    We want justice for CM Arvind Kejriwal , Manish Sisodia Sir and Satyander Jain Sir 🎉🎉 . CJI Chandrachud please 🙏 intervene and dissolve this case .

  • Reply
    @rmnair90 June 19, 2024

    Thoroughly absorbing discussion. Very well anchored. Especially appreciated his intervention in asking Sr Adv Rohatgi to briefly explain a Sec.
    👏👏👏👏👏

  • Reply
    @arvindiyer4995 June 19, 2024

    Very insightful. Question is whether this discussion will take place in the parliament?
    Will the President of India step in and push for a debate?

  • Reply
    @lalsawirema1383 June 19, 2024

    Many provision was amended in Crpc, Ipc & Evidence. This old Act is a refined of judicial review, denuding with new Act is not wise.

  • Reply
    @kripanandbajpai4662 June 19, 2024

    We have our own legislation not of Britain's as IPC,I e. Indian penal code, Indian evidence act,crpc 1974. So how the bjp has called Britishers law.
    Our all above laws have been amended from time to time.
    The only two reasons for making the new laws are 1/ making more stringent laws n procedures so that people may not speak against BJP government by making the police state 2/ modi may substitute ambedkar by calling him the first man who had legislated the Indian laws.Because overall no new law introduced except changing the number as 302:101 so on which will take hundred years to make an impact upon general public.
    With all that humility at my command,I will venture to submit that judiciary specially the lower use to act an clerk of police when they seek remand whether PCR or judicial.it has ruined the system.
    For your kind information the law of sk antil, given by sc after putting the longest time n energy,it's not being followed by lower courts (sessions court,) after some time.tiday is 19/6/24

  • Reply
    @ikkubangalore June 19, 2024

    Kabil sibal is the culprit of neet exam issue

  • Reply
    @ambrose12345able June 19, 2024

    The BJP govt must be abolished before any amendment is brought in force. The BJP is worse than the British government. There are more fools now than when they ruled us.

  • Reply
    @NanaBABU349 June 19, 2024

    Actions do not show dharma by speakers

  • Reply
    @BH-yl1ni June 19, 2024

    Why Kapil Sibbal and Abhishek Manu Singhvi are worried about new laws? Our Courts sit twice on the very same Saturday evening, open at midnight at their instance or give bail even when not saught for‼️ We common public can't afford them, hence our cries get burried in long waits for Justice, many a times for generations or as our President M'am described, behind bars for petty crimes just because there is no one to apply/give guarantee even for the tiny amount of the bail😢😢😢
    Instead of such discussion, please tell us how our common man's children can get selected by the collegium and chair the process of Justice in this democracy – we please don't want dynasty ruling even judiciary at the cost of taxpayers – we are paying taxes for benefit of the nation as a whole, we are not paying jazia under which we won't have right to raise our voice against the use of our money just taken forcefully……. wondering why I am telling you all this when we don't have right to tell where and how our money paid in temples after paying all taxes should be used😡🤯

  • Reply
    @sanjayseroha4219 June 19, 2024

    These lawyers are talking about hard laws that doesn’t grant bails. These are same people who represent criminals, mafias, corrupt politicians for money. What right do they have to talk about ethics in law.

  • Reply
    @SelvarajC-dc7xh June 19, 2024

    See corruption index justice index and poverty index etc. Indian laws are skewed in favour of rich and powerful. Nothing happened in Bofors, Rafael, 2G etc. lalit Modi Nirav Modi choksi mallya are enjoying life with taxpayers money. What happened to criminal law of india?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X
Enable Notifications OK No thanks
Verified by MonsterInsights