Eliantes Jean Jacques, a Haitian immigrant who has lived in Florida for more than three decades, is long familiar with the political instability, economic turmoil, and natural disasters that have left his homeland teetering on the precipice of collapse.
But Haiti’s recent descent into gang-fueled lawlessness and chaos, Jean Jacques said, seems more ominous. The gangs appear to have more guns than the police, who have all but disappeared. Armed groups control ports and major roads. Inmates have been freed from jails. Gangs have shut down the airport. They run rampant as kidnappings and murders spread rapidly beyond the capital of Port-au-Prince.
Jean Jacques, 66, said in a phone interview that since February his 55-year-old brother and a 36-year-old cousin have been killed by the armed groups. He has not heard from his brother’s children or two cousins in Haiti since last week.
“I’m afraid gangs will kill them. They don’t care,” said Jean Jacques, a cook in North Miami. “I cry and cry. I don’t know what’s going to happen.”
In Florida, home to more than 270,000 people born in Haiti, residents with ties to the impoverished nation spend hours checking on friends and loved ones coping with homelessness, dwindling food supplies, violence and uncertainty. Community leaders and some elected officials question the decision of Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican, to deploy more than 250 law enforcement officers and soldiers to the Florida Keys to “protect our state” and stop a possible surge of Haitian migrants fleeing the violence.
Tessa Petit, executive director of the Florida Immigrant Coalition and a native of Haiti, criticized the state’s attempt to respond to the long evolving Haiti crisis with “more violence and militarization.”
“I have family members who have had to leave Haiti and moved to the Dominican Republic,” said Petit, whose coalition is part of a vast network of organizations providing services to the Florida’s Haitian community. “It gets worse day after a day. People are dying. More and more businesses are being burned to the ground. Whatever was left is being completely destroyed.”
A migrant surge has yet to materialize, though previous crises have forced Haitians to risk their lives by taking to the sea in hopes of reaching Florida.
“We have always been on high alert knowing that the way Haiti has been that people will take to the sea,” Petit said. “We do know that when a country is closed, the borders are closed, the airports are closed, and people are trying to flee to safety, then they’re going to do whatever they can. To think that people would rather risk dying in high seas than staying home is just a confirmation of how dangerous Haiti is.”
See what happened after CNN crew arrives in Haiti
On Wednesday, DeSantis announced that he was sending additional personnel – including more than 130 soldiers – to the Keys, along with more than a dozen aircraft and boats, to stop what his office called the “possibility of invasion” by Haitian migrants. The deployment includes officers from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission officers, and members of the Florida National Guard and Florida State Guard.
The US Coast Guard said Tuesday that it had repatriated 65 migrants to Haiti after they were picked up on a boat near the Bahamas. Since October 1, the Coast Guard said, it has repatriated 131 migrants to Haiti.
The Coast Guard said it has not seen an increase in migrants from Haiti in recent weeks.
DeSantis’ office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
“We’ve sort of been there before,” said Gepsie Metellus, executive director of the Sant La Haitian Neighborhood Center in North Miami, referring to previous crisis-fueled surges in migration from Haiti.
“And we always in the end harness the community resources to be able to to assist with any influx. So, are we expecting more people? Well, you know, people have been trickling in before things erupted to where we are today. Are there more people coming? It’s very likely.”
The situation in Haiti deteriorates by the day. Beleaguered Prime Minister Ariel Henry announced his decision to step aside, but it is not clear who will fill the void or when. A transitional government has yet to materialize, and plans for a Kenyan-led stabilization force have stalled.
Residents leave their homes only rarely in Port-au-Prince as daily gun battles between police and gangs break out in the streets. The United Nations is planning an air bridge between Port-au-Prince and Santo Domingo, in the neighboring Dominican Republic, in an effort to bring vital supplies to the city.
Eighty percent of Port-au-Prince is now controlled by gangs, according to UN estimates. Haiti was thrown into crisis at the start of March, as gangs called for the resignation of Henry and his government.
The country is facing its most crippling security crisis in years, with some 5.5 million people – about half the population – in need of humanitarian assistance.
Henry came to power unelected in 2021 after the assassination of Haiti’s then-President Jovenel Moïse. Henry’s tenure has been marred by spiraling gang violence, which intensified after he failed to hold elections last month, saying the country’s insecurity would compromise the vote. On Monday, amid enormous pressure to staunch the violence, Henry stepped down.
“Everybody who has friends or family in Haiti, we wake up every day, and we check our phones to make sure whether or not we hear the news of a friend or family member who’s been attacked, whose house has been completely destroyed, who has died,” Petit said. “It’s hard to live with so much stress on a daily basis.”
Haitian community leaders and elected officials in Florida accuse DeSantis of playing politics with the plight of vulnerable refugees.
“Rather than harass refugees who are literally fleeing for their lives, to make it look like he’s doing something with a show of force at the southern end of the state, we can focus state law enforcement resources on working with federal partners to make sure shipments from Florida are throughly screened for illegal arms and munitions,” said Florida state Rep. Dotie Joseph, a Democrat who represents North Miami and was born in Haiti.
“We need to treat those fleeing violence with dignity and compassion, rather than manipulating the situation for political gain.”
CNN’s Caitlin Stephen Hu, David Culver, Evelio Contreras, Tara John, Carlos Suarez and Denise Royal contributed to this report.
Join Our Newsletter
Get the latest crime news and updates directly to your inbox. [newsletter]
28 Comments
I wonder if this is a humanitarian response or a political move?
Who knows? Maybe its a bit of both. Its rare for actions to be purely humanitarian or political these days. Lets hope the end result benefits those in need, regardless of the motives behind it.
Is deploying military the right move? Lets discuss the impact on migrants.
Is deploying military the right move? What about compassion for migrants?
Military force is necessary to protect our borders and national security. Compassion for migrants cannot come at the expense of our safety and sovereignty. Tough decisions must be made to ensure the well-being of our country.
Are we really prepared for this influx? Shouldnt we focus on humanitarian aid instead?
We can do both. Providing humanitarian aid is crucial, but we also need to address the root causes of the influx to prevent future crises. Its about finding a balance and being proactive in our approach.
Is deploying military personnel the best solution for handling Haitian migrants?
Deploying military personnel may not be the ideal solution for handling Haitian migrants. Diplomatic efforts, humanitarian aid, and collaboration with international organizations could be more effective in addressing the root causes of migration. Lets prioritize compassion and long-term solutions over militarization.
Shouldnt we focus on humanitarian aid rather than military deployment?
Shouldnt we focus on humanitarian aid instead of military deployment?
Military deployment can provide security and stability, creating a safer environment for humanitarian aid to be delivered. Sometimes, a strong military presence is necessary to ensure the safety of aid workers and the success of relief efforts. Both military and humanitarian efforts can work hand in hand to achieve positive outcomes.
Is deploying military the best solution or should Florida provide humanitarian aid?
Deploying the military should be a last resort. Florida should prioritize humanitarian aid to address the root causes of the issue. Violence only begets more violence. Lets show compassion and use diplomacy before resorting to force.
Why is military intervention the first response? What about humanitarian aid?
This is a volatile situation. Will the military intervention do more harm than good?
Isnt it concerning how quickly the government deploys military for migrants?
Its the governments duty to protect its borders and maintain national security. Migrants must enter legally to ensure safety for all. Quick military deployment may be necessary in certain situations. Lets trust in our leaders to make the right decisions for our countrys well-being.
Shouldnt we focus on humanitarian aid rather than military deployment for Haitian migrants?
Why deploy military? Are there better solutions? Lets discuss alternatives.
Do we really need military intervention for a humanitarian crisis?
Do you think deploying military personnel is the right move? Seems extreme.
Absolutely, deploying military personnel is necessary to protect our countrys interests. Sometimes extreme measures are required to ensure national security. Trust in the decisions made by our leaders who have access to classified information and expertise in these matters.
Is deploying military personnel the right approach to handle Haitian migrant influx?
Deploying military personnel may be necessary to secure borders and ensure order. The influx of Haitian migrants requires a strong response to manage the situation effectively. Diplomacy alone may not be enough to address the challenges posed by large-scale migration.
Why is the military needed for migrants? Seems excessive.
The military provides necessary resources and expertise for border security. Migrant influxes can overwhelm civilian agencies, necessitating military support. Its about protecting our borders and ensuring national security. Your perspective overlooks the complexities of the situation.
Why not focus on providing aid instead of deploying military? Priorities, people!