Introducing ‘Shane & Sally’: Texas Monthly’s Newest Podcast

Shane Stewart and Sally McNelly disappeared on July 4, 1988, after going out for the night in San Angelo, Texas. Despite numerous investigations over the past 35 years, their murders remain unsolved. Key evidence has gone missing while new clues, such as Sally’s driver’s license being found on the floor of the San Angelo Police Department and incriminating items found in a suspect’s home, have surfaced. Speculations about the killer’s identity range from a former police officer to a suspect who fled the country. Texas Monthly’s new podcast series, Shane & Sally, delves into the case with exclusive access to investigators, friends, and suspects who have never spoken publicly about the case before.

The podcast series explores the mysterious murders of Shane and Sally against the backdrop of occult rituals, drug deals, kidnapping, and corruption in a small West Texas town during the “Satanic panic” era. Hosted by Rob D’Amico and Karen Jacobs, the series promises to reveal new information and insights into the case that has baffled investigators and haunted the victims’ family and friends for decades. The first two episodes will be released on March 19, providing listeners with an inside look at the case and the various theories surrounding the identities of the killers.

Listeners can expect a deep dive into the Shane and Sally murder case, with interviews from investigators, examination of case records, and insights from friends and suspects who have remained silent until now. The podcast aims to shed light on the events leading up to the teenagers’ disappearance, the subsequent investigation, and the lingering questions that remain unanswered. Bonus videos and additional content related to the series will be available on the Texas Monthly website, allowing listeners to explore the case further and engage with the material presented in the podcast.

The Shane & Sally podcast series not only focuses on the search for justice for the victims but also highlights the impact of the murders on their loved ones and the community. The unresolved case has left a lasting mark on San Angelo, with generations of investigators and residents grappling with the mystery of what happened to Shane and Sally that fateful night. By bringing new perspectives and information to light, the podcast seeks to reinvigorate interest in the case and potentially uncover new leads that could finally bring closure to this long-standing cold case.

To engage with the podcast and share thoughts or information related to the murders of Shane Stewart and Sally McNelly, listeners are encouraged to interact with the Texas Monthly team through the provided form on their website. By soliciting feedback and insights from the public, the podcast creators hope to foster a collaborative effort in unraveling the truth behind the tragic deaths of these two teenagers and potentially bringing those responsible to justice. Tune in to Shane & Sally on Apple Podcasts or your preferred listening platform to follow the investigation and delve into the mysteries surrounding this perplexing case.