Dr Nandipha Magudumana’s lawyer, Machini Motloung, is demanding that she be moved to another prison cell after she was allegedly assaulted over the weekend. Magudumana contacted Motloung to report the assault, stating that she was in pain and had suffered bruises while in custody at the Kroonstad Correctional Centre in the Free State. Motloung claims that Magudumana was allegedly assaulted by a sangoma and a mentally-ill woman, following tensions that had been building up between them.
Motloung stated that Magudumana had been receiving threats of violence and had reported them to the relevant authorities, but no action was taken. The issues between Magudumana and the other inmates involved in the assault reportedly stemmed from singing and prayer sessions in the cell. According to Motloung, the tensions escalated on Sunday when Magudumana was assaulted, prompting him to demand her relocation to a safer cell. He also mentioned his intention to file a complaint with the South African Human Rights Commission to ensure his client’s safety.
The spokesperson for the Department of Correctional Services, Singabakho Nxumalo, stated that they had not received any complaints from Magudumana or her legal representatives regarding the assault. Nxumalo disputed claims that mentally challenged inmates are housed with other inmates, as they are under the jurisdiction of the Department of Health. He also refuted allegations that Magudumana was assaulted by police while en route to a court appearance, stating that she was not escorted by police officials and that no complaints or medical reports were filed.
It was revealed that Magudumana is the co-accused in the Thabo Bester prison escape case, with Bester currently in custody at the Kgosi Mampuru II prison in Pretoria. Motloung’s concern for Magudumana’s safety in prison has sparked a call for her transfer to a cell where her life will not be endangered. The lawyer’s efforts to ensure his client’s well-being highlight the importance of addressing threats of violence and security risks faced by inmates while in custody, and the need for proper investigations and measures to be taken.
The alleged assault on Magudumana raises questions about the safety and security of inmates within the correctional system and emphasizes the importance of addressing grievances and complaints from those in custody. Motloung’s advocacy for his client’s protection and his plans to involve the South African Human Rights Commission underscore the need for accountability and transparency in ensuring the well-being of individuals in detention. The response from the Department of Correctional Services and their denial of receiving any complaints regarding the assault highlights the potential challenges in addressing issues of violence and safety within correctional facilities.
Join Our Newsletter
Get the latest crime news and updates directly to your inbox. [newsletter]
24 Comments
Should the Sangoma be held responsible for the assault? Lets discuss!
Absolutely not. The Sangomas role is to provide spiritual guidance, not to control peoples actions. Blaming them for the assault is absurd. Personal responsibility lies with the individual who committed the act. Lets focus on accountability where it truly belongs.
This story raises questions about mental health care in our justice system.
Should Sangomas be allowed in prisons for mental health treatment?
Do we need more mental health support in prisons? Lets discuss.
Absolutely, mental health support in prisons is crucial. It not only benefits the inmates but also contributes to overall safety and rehabilitation efforts. Neglecting mental health only perpetuates a cycle of violence and recidivism. Lets prioritize this issue for a more humane and effective justice system.
What a bizarre story, what are your thoughts on the connection between Sangoma and mental illness?
Whats the real story behind this bizarre incident? So many unanswered questions!
This article raises questions about mental health care in correctional facilities.
Mental health care in prisons is a disgrace. Inmates deserve proper treatment, not neglect. Its a basic human right. Time for change!
Should traditional healers be held accountable for their patients actions? 🤔
Traditional healers should not be held accountable for their patients actions. Each individual is responsible for their own choices and behavior. Blaming healers for their patients actions is unfair and misguided. Personal accountability is key in any situation.
This raises important questions about mental health treatment in prisons.
Is there a thin line between cultural beliefs and mental illness?
Do you think the Sangomas involvement influenced the inmates actions?
Should we consider traditional beliefs in cases involving mental illness?
Absolutely not. Traditional beliefs have no place in cases involving mental illness. Its dangerous and irresponsible to rely on outdated practices instead of evidence-based treatments. Lets prioritize science and compassion over superstition.
Can we trust Sangomas to work with mentally ill individuals?
This case raises questions about mental health care in prisons. Whats your take?
Should mental health care in prisons be improved to prevent incidents like this?
Do we truly understand the complexities of mental illness and traditional beliefs?
Traditional beliefs often perpetuate harmful stigmas surrounding mental illness, hindering progress in understanding and treatment. Its time to challenge outdated notions and embrace a more compassionate and informed approach. Lets prioritize empathy and education over ignorance and prejudice.
Should traditional healers be held accountable for their patients actions?
Do you think the involvement of a Sangoma in the assault case is relevant?