July 5, 2024
Sex Crimes

DISCUSSION | Controversial court judgment on issue of sexual consent: Lisa Vetten & Modidima Mannya



The controversial court judgment on the issue of sexual consent could undermine South Africa’s quest to assert the human rights of women, according to a legal expert. This comes after acting Eastern Cape High Court Judge Tembeka Ngcukaitobi overturned the conviction of a former paramedic who was found guilty of raping his girlfriend because, by agreeing to oral sex, Ngcukaitobi ruled – she had tacitly agreed to penetrative sex. She was a virgin.
Joining SABC News Chriselda Lewis to discuss this are Lisa Vetten from Research/Project Consultant in the Gender Violence and Urban Transformations Project, and Adv Modidima Mannya, Legal Analyst and Public Commentator.

For more news, visit sabcnews.com and also #SABCNews #Coronavirus #COVID19News #Covid-19Vaccination #Vaccine on Social Media.

source

6 Comments

  • @lvdeluxe1 June 29, 2024

    Men stay away from these modern women. They're not worth a cent or a second.

    They pull off their panties, open their legs and then send you to court for doing something about it. Total Bull.

  • @sbuskosana2281 June 29, 2024

    Its going to be difficult to have sexual intercourse.

  • So it is ok for a woman to be confused over what her boyfriend is doing, she is forgiven just like that. But the boyfriend must not be given the same benefit, instead he must be harshly punished for having sex with a confused girlfriend who seemed to be enjoying the experience? It sounds like BS to me.

  • @bigmac3049 June 29, 2024

    Why did they bring a karen?

  • @xthewixard June 29, 2024

    So the interpretation is technically correct, albeit conservative. Well, I suppose that's one way to lower the high levels of sexual violence in South Africa — just interpret them out of existence. Done!

  • no no no you got it wrong Sakhina. if you read the judgement it talks about the state failing to convince the court, it does not say consent to foreplay is the consent to penetration.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X
Enable Notifications OK No thanks
Verified by MonsterInsights