DNA testing experts took the stand in a Rockland courtroom to argue that Dennis Dechaine deserves a new trial after spending over three decades in prison for the murder of 12-year-old Sarah Cherry in 1988. Dechaine has consistently maintained his innocence in the case, where DNA testing from 2022 revealed that his DNA was not present on several items at the crime scene. However, state prosecutors have disputed this interpretation of the new evidence, claiming there is still overwhelming evidence against Dechaine.
During the hearing at Knox County Superior Court, Dechaine’s defense team highlighted the results of the 2022 DNA testing to support their argument for a retrial. Defense attorney John Nale questioned the analyst who conducted the testing and an independent expert witness called by the defense. Nale argued that the new DNA evidence showed blood found under Sarah’s fingernails did not belong to her, but to another man who ultimately murdered her. He pointed out that the DNA in the blood did not match Dechaine’s.
Forensic analyst Gary Harmor testified that the DNA under Sarah’s fingernails could potentially match that found on a scarf used to strangle her. Another defense witness, Rick Staub, claimed there were similarities between the two samples despite degradation over time. However, Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber criticized the new DNA evidence, highlighting supposed gaps in the data and arguing that DNA evidence alone may not be conclusive.
In response to Macomber’s doubts, Harmor acknowledged that factors such as wearing gloves, shedding DNA, and exposure to the elements could influence the quality and quantity of DNA samples. Macomber reiterated his skepticism about the significance of DNA evidence, stating that it may not be as decisive as claimed. The defense team will need to convince Justice Bruce Mallonee that the new evidence could lead to a different verdict in order to secure a new trial for Dechaine.
Despite the ongoing legal battle, state prosecutors have continued to point to other evidence linking Dechaine to Sarah’s murder, including items found near the crime scene and the location where her body was discovered. Dechaine’s supporters, organized under a group called Trial and Error, have rallied behind him, attending court proceedings and raising funds for his defense. The case has garnered widespread attention, with Dechaine’s innocence still fiercely debated among those who believe in his cause.
In the courtroom, Dechaine interacted with his supporters, exchanging nods and words with them throughout the proceedings. The emotional and complex nature of the case has gripped the community and drawn both local and national interest. As the hearing continues and arguments are presented on both sides, the fate of Dennis Dechaine hangs in the balance, awaiting a decision that could determine the course of his future and the resolution of a decades-old mystery.
Join Our Newsletter
Get the latest crime news and updates directly to your inbox.